#UFC London #Fabricio Werdum #Conor McGregor #UFC 222 #Alexander Volkov #Khabib Nurmagomedov #Francis Ngannou #Tony Ferguson #Holly Holm #Fight Night Rotterdam #UFC 217 - Madison Square Garden

John McCarthy: Different rules across MMA commissions not fair to fighters, officials or fans

MMA is no stranger to confusing and conflicting rule interpretations these days, and the sport’s most well-known referee says it’s a big problem.

Relatively speaking, “Big” John McCarthy recently told MMAjunkie Radio the sport of MMA is so new that it’s like the early days of American football. He said MMA is a little past the days of football players wearing leather helmets with no facemasks – but it’s still early.

“The truth is, (right now) we’re the single-bar (helmet) or the double-bar (helmet),” McCarthy said. “The leather helmet (era) is when we weren’t allowed to stop the fights, no rules – stuff like that.”

But the biggest issue McCarthy sees with the sport right now is that despite the Unified Rules of MMA, different state athletic commissions have different rule interpretations, and it causes confusion for the fighters, the referees and especially the fans.

“You look at the NFL – the NFL is a business where no matter if they go to New York or Wisconsin in Green Bay, they go down to Dallas or San Francisco, they are an organization that runs the officials, that runs the sport of football for professionals,” McCarthy said. “With that, they have rules committees that meet every year – they go about coming up with new rules they think are going to benefit the sport, the participants, try to make things better for the fans and knowing what should be done in a certain situation.

“The problem with MMA is, we have all of these athletic commissions, and each athletic commission is an entity unto itself. The athletic commission can do what it wants, and that’s the problem we have with MMA. It’s not fair to the fighters, it’s not fair to the officials, it’s not fair to the fans.”

Fighters frequently remind the media, and the fans, that the fans are who pays their bills, and that they fight for the fans, not just for money or title runs. And McCarthy believes the rules changing from commission to commisison have a negative impact on the fans paying to see shows live, or watching them on TV.

“They care that they’re seeing the sport that they like and they know exactly what is allowed in that sport and what is not,” he said. “But when it changes from state to state, that causes a problem for the fans because fans don’t know what can be done. They don’t know what’s right.”

In addition, a fighter in the UFC or Bellator might fight in Las Vegas, then Kansas City, Mo., then New York, then Brazil – and it’s conceivable that there are different rule intracacies in each of those locations. And that means the potential for the need for rule interpretations by officials who have to know all those intracacies.

It’s no wonder that from time to time, the sport sees a controversial ending to a fight – like Gegard Mousasi’s recent win over Chris Weidman at UFC 210 in Buffalo, N.Y.

“It’s a problem for fighters because fighters travel,” McCarthy said. “The low-level fighters are fighting in their state, and they’ll fight multiple times in their state, so they get used to that rule set. But if you’re a top-level fighter and you do one show in California and it’s under the Unifed Rules of MMA, and then you go to Missouri and they say, ‘Oh, we have a different set of rules,’ you just affected that fighter in a bad way. You should care about that, but that’s not what’s happening.”

For more on the upcoming MMA schedule, stay tuned to the MMA Rumors section of the site.

MMAjunkie Radio broadcasts Monday-Friday at 1 p.m. ET (10 a.m. PT) live from Mandalay Bay Resort & Casino’s Race & Sports Book. The show is hosted by “Gorgeous” George Garcia and producer Brian “Goze” Garcia. For more information or to download past episodes, go to www.mmajunkie.com/radio.

view original article >>
Report here if this news is invalid.


Show Comments

Related News

Video: It turns out John McCarthy is pretty good behind the scenes, as well

  • 19 days ago

“Big” John McCarthy is one of the best officials in MMA history, but he may be a bit of a natural at this broadcasting thing, too. read news >>

Marcin Tybura knows fans won't like him when he fights Derrick Lewis in UFC-Austin co-headliner

  • 27 days ago

Marcin Tybura knows he’ll be getting some boos when he fights Texas’ own Derrick Lewis, but he’s hoping the few Polish fans at UFC Fight Night 121 make up for the rest of the crowd. read news >>

UFC Fight Night 126 draws announced 10,502 fans for $794,350 live gate in Austin

  • 26 days ago

Sunday’s UFC Fight Night 126 event drew an announced attendance of 10,502 fans and a live gate of $794,350. read news >>

Fans invited to open workouts, weigh-ins for UFC on FOX 28 in Orlando

  • 25 days ago

If you’re heading to Central Florida for this week’s UFC on FOX 28 card, you have some fight-week events you can attend for free. read news >>

Marc Diakiese calls out Mr. Sage Northcutt by politely asking in fluent 'super' language

  • 24 days ago

Sage Northcutt is no stranger to getting called out, but at least Marc Diakiese kept it G-rated when he put in his request with UFC brass. read news >>

Derrick Lewis vs. Francis Ngannou? UFC starts pushing matchup; 'Black Beast' indifferent

  • 24 days ago

UFC officials have started a small push for a potential matchup between contenders Derrick Lewis and Francis Ngannou. read news >>

Michael Chiesa explains how he's reinvented himself for Anthony Pettis bout at UFC 223

  • 24 days ago

Michael Chiesa expects fans to see a new version of him when he fights Anthony Pettis at UFC 223. read news >>

Daily Debate: Is Nate Diaz good for MMA and the UFC?

  • 24 days ago

MMA fans love Nate Diaz. Or maybe they just love – really love – to hate the UFC vet. read news >>

Vitor Belfort's Retirement Bout vs. Lyoto Machida Official for UFC 224 | MMAWeekly.com

  • 24 days ago

Officials made the highly anticipated Brazilian vs. Brazilian showdown between Vitor Belfort and Lyoto Machida official on Tuesday. read news >>

Thursday's Fight Nights Global 83 set to stream free from Moscow

  • 23 days ago

Thursday’s “Fight Nights Global 83: Alibekov vs. Aliev” will stream live and free, promotion officials today told MMAjunkie. read news >>

Israel Adesanya meets Marvin Vettori at UFC on FOX 29 in Arizona

  • 21 days ago

UFC officials aren’t waiting long to get “The Last Stylebender” back in the cage. read news >>

UFC on FOX 28 results: Alan Jouban KOs friend Ben Saunders in memorable scrap

  • 20 days ago

Alan Jouban spoiled Ben Saunders’ fight in front of his home fans in Orlando with a walkoff knockout in the second round. read news >>

Did Jeremy Stephens not know the rules, or did he just know that they don't matter?

  • 20 days ago

We can disagree over whether or not he succeeded, but clearly Jeremy Stephens was trying to land a knee to the head of a downed opponent. read news >>

Why can't MMA have unified rules that are actually, you know, unified?

  • 19 days ago

We call it the “unified rules” of MMA, but different state athletic commissions can still have wildly different rules for fights, weigh-ins, and even the tools at the disposal of the officials. This read news >>

Fans invited to open workouts, weigh-ins for UFC 222 in Las Vegas

  • 18 days ago

If you’re heading to “Sin City” for this week’s UFC 222 card, you have some fight-week events you can attend for free. read news >>

Watch MMAjunkie Radio here (1 p.m. ET) with John McCarthy, Sam Alvey

  • 18 days ago

MMAjunkie Radio kicks off today at 1 p.m. ET (10 a.m. PT) with guests John McCarthy and Sam Alvey. read news >>

Search for:

Related Videos

Trending News

Top News