phil-davis-vinny-magalhaes.jpgPhil Davis is a smart guy. Too smart to do something dumb when he faced Vinny Magalhaes this past month at UFC 159, which makes you wonder about the line between smart and safe in MMA, and between safe and boring.

You see, Davis may have talked up a desire to submit Magalhaes in the run-up to the fight, but as he explained on MMAjunkie Radio recently, he actually felt no obligation to attack the jiu-jitsu ace where he was strongest, just to prove some point.

“If I find a weakness, I will beat you there,” Davis said, adding later, “I don’t need to prove how big of a man I am and fight with some huge ego and try to submit you where you’re strongest just to prove I’m this or that. That’s not the way I do things. That’s not the way you win a war. That’s not the way you do anything successfully. Not in competition.”

He’s right, of course. The way Davis opted to pick apart Magalhaes from a comfortable distance was completely unassailable from a tactical perspective. He got the decision, got his money, and went home a winner. So what does it say that the Davis-Magalhaes bout was so forgettable while Jon Jones‘ decision to beat Chael Sonnen at his own game managed to make an obvious mismatch seem memorable?

You can’t really criticize Davis for his approach. If he’d stuck around in Magalhaes’ guard and gotten himself submitted, we’d all be talking about how dumb it was to play to his opponent’s strengths. That’s how you become a cautionary tale in MMA. That’s not the way you accumulate victories and pocket win bonuses.

At the same time, I can’t say that it was a whole lot of fun to watch Davis use his strengths to exploit Magalhaes’ weaknesses for three rounds. It felt kind of like watching a movie where, 20 minutes in, you know exactly what the next hour and a half will look like. No twists. No surprises. No climactic scene where you realize that, oh my god, Kevin Spacey is Keyser Soze. The third round looked an awful lot like the first, only with more sweat and heavier breathing.

If that’s what a smart strategy looks like in this sport, and if we’re not too psyched about it once we see it, what does that say about us? Do we prefer dumb game plans, in practice if not in theory? Or is it predictability that we tire of, so much so that we’d rather see a fighter attempt an ill-advised surprise instead of taking the well-paved road to certain victory?

It probably depends a lot on the fighter in question. For instance, elsewhere on the same fight card, we saw Roy Nelson knock out Cheick Kongo with the same shot put of a right hand that he’s become famous for. That was exciting, but it wasn’t terribly surprising. That’s what Nelson does. Especially when he’s fighting a guy who probably can’t take him down, and probably wouldn’t want to be on the mat with him even if he could, it makes sense for him to stand around and wait for a good look at the other guy’s chin. And since fans love to see heavyweights thump each other’s skulls, it’s not like anyone is going to complain about “Big Country” doing the same old thing.

It’s different when you’re a fighter like Davis. His wrestling chops let him decide where the fight takes place, but they don’t necessarily help him finish it. That’s how he ends up winning smart, yet still defending his strategy to fans who were holding out hope that he might do something dumb, or at least unexpected.

That’s the problem with smart game plans. They also tend to be risk-averse, and, in addition to pure, unadulterated violence, risk is a big part of the appeal of combat sports. That’s what fight promoters sell. This guy will try to hit this other guy and, in so doing, will open himself up to being hit. So when someone finds a way to win that a) minimizes risk, and b) doesn’t replace it with a bloody abundance of the aforementioned violence, it can feel like a letdown, maybe even a bore.

Is that a good enough reason for fighters like Davis to abandon their strengths in the interest of entertainment? Probably not, especially when you consider that if he’d tried it and lost, it’s not like we’d cut him much slack for his willingness to step out of his comfort zone. That’s why fighting is such a selfish sport. The fighter has to look out for his own interests – because fans and promoters sure won’t.

Davis did what was best for him, and that’s smart. Smart wins fights. Smart keeps your bones intact and your teeth in your mouth. It’s safe that way. It’s just that safe doesn’t necessarily put butts in seats or contenders in title fights. Not in a sport where, when we talk about excitement, we’re really talking about a particular brand of chaos.

(Pictured: Phil Davis and Vinny Magalhaes)

view original article >>
Report here if this news is invalid.

Related News

Lightweight Melvin Guillard signs with Bellator

  • 22 days ago
  • 1 views

Melvin Guillard's rocky World Series of Fighting tenure is now in the past as the lightweight has signed with Bellator. The next chapter in Melvin Guillard's up-and-down career will take place inside read news >>

A written apology, an accidental historian, and tough questions for relics of MMA's past

  • 24 days ago
  • 16 views

The letter is dated March 22, 1996, addressed to the Semaphore Entertainment Group, expressing a “heartfelt apology.” Where it is now, and how it came to be there, highlights a tricky question for th read news >>

By The Numbers: Fifth Round Finishes

  • 25 days ago
  • 1 views

This past Saturday night, UFC flyweight champion Demetrious Johnson secured an armbar on challenger Kyoji Horiguchi and forced the tap with one second remaining in their five-round title fight at read news >>

Nik Lentz happy beating up Brazilians: 'Hopefully they learn to love me'

  • 25 days ago
  • 2 views

Despite going 4-1 in his past five fights, losing only to divisional standout Chad Mendes in that run, Nik Lentz doesn’t always seem to get the respect he believes he deserves. But this year, he plan read news >>

Making the Case for Ronda Rousey as the Pound-for-Pound Best in MMA

  • 26 days ago
  • 2 views

Over the past few years, only Jon Jones and Jose Aldo have been nearly as dominant over their divisions in the UFC as Ronda Rousey has. Despite recent off-the-Octagon issues, Jones is still undeniabl read news >>

Anthony Johnson: 'The gameplan hasn't changed; the gameplan is to whoop some ass'

  • 26 days ago
  • 2 views

While much has changed for Anthony Johnson over the past few days, the UFC light heavyweight contender said his plan for May 23 hasn’t been altered one bit.Filed under: News, UFC read news >>

Champ Demetrious Johnson: My record is going to be very, very hard to break

  • 27 days ago
  • 6 views

With four finishes in his past five fights, UFC flyweight champion Demetrious Johnson has a lot to smile about. Even better, he’s now a record-holder in the promotion for the latest submission in a U read news >>

Video: Go behind the scenes of UFC 186 in Montreal in 'The Thrill and Agony'

  • 27 days ago
  • 1 views

The UFC returned to Canada this past week for UFC 186, featuring a flyweight title fight and some history. See the UFC’s new video “The Thrill and Agony” to go behind the scenes in Montreal.Filed und read news >>

The Question: How Should the UFC Handle the Jon Jones Problem?

  • 28 days ago
  • 8 views

Unless you've been living under a rock the past two days, you know all about the current shenanigans surrounding UFC light heavyweight champion Jon Jones. Just in case, here's a quick recap: Jones wa read news >>