Judging is currently one of the most heated subjects of debate in the world of mixed martial arts. This past weekend’s UFC 131 in Vancouver only served to fan the flames.

Darren Elkins and Michihiro Omigawa at UFC 131

Darren Elkins and Michihiro Omigawa at UFC 131

There were several decisions brought into question at Rogers Arena, but none that rivaled the backlash over the night’s opening bout between Darren Elkins and Michihiro Omigawa, which aired live on Facebook and YouTube.

It was a back-and-forth fight with both fighters getting in their licks, though most people watching felt Omigawa had bested his opponent. In the end, however, all three judges scored the bout in Elkins’ favor, two of them 29-28, the third 30-27.

As soon as Elkins was declared the winner the backlash began. The online forums and, of course, Twitter, blew up with comments decrying the decision. Not easily missed among those incredulous over the decision was UFC president Dana White.

“Then you’ve got the Omigawa fight, where this guy loses the fight and Joe Silva said he was pulling a (Kazushi) Sakuraba and wasn’t going to leave the Octagon. He was going to stay in there, Joe had to beg him to leave,” said White after the post-fight press conference, discussing his criticism of the state of MMA judging.

“We’re going to pay him his win money. I don’t care what the judge said; he won the fight. I say he won, overruled.”

That of course takes care of Omigawa’s pocketbook, but it doesn’t change his official record, which now reflects back-to-back losses in the Octagon following a five-fight winning streak.

The backlash over the decision was strong enough that the Vancouver Athletic Commission decided to comment on the scoring of the fight.

“In the first round, Elkins backed Omigawa up with punches the entire round. He controlled the center of the cage. He was throwing a lot more shots, and landing more — and in combination,” Commissioner Jonathan Tweedale told MMAWeekly.com via email, commenting on behalf of the commission.

“If there is any controversy as to the outcome of the fight it must be because of the second round. That was a very challenging round to score. An argument can be made in favor of either fighter.

“Elkins landed more punches. At one point, when Omigawa came forward, he was stopped dead in his tracks by Elkins’ combination punches, and at another point he was slightly buckled. Due to Omigawa’s unusual stance and balance, it was difficult to tell exactly whether he was rocked by some of these shots. However, you could see Omigawa’s leg bend, and the control shift to Elkins as he landed the combo, stopping Omigawa in his tracks, taking the center of the cage, and going on the attack again.

“These sequences, as well as the total effective strikes landed, could reasonably warrant awarding the round to Elkins. Elkins didn’t land many more than Omigawa, but he did land more.  (The Fightmetric numbers agree.) As to the blood – it represents something, but a cut can be caused by a glancing blow, and some fighters just cut more readily than others.

“That’s a round about which reasonable people can disagree. Close rounds like Round 2 of Omigawa vs. Elkins serve as useful examples for discussion, to assist in refining and evolving the community’s understanding of the scoring criteria, generally. And that is a good thing for the sport.”

Tweedale fell short of giving his personal opinion on the decision, but more or less opened the floor for debate over the criteria used in the 10-point must system of scoring that has been carried over from the boxing world.

The official Elkins vs. Omigawa scorecard. (Click to enlarge)

Under the 10-point must system that most people are used to, a fighter is awarded scores per round then those scores are added up at the end of the fight to declare a winner.

There isn’t much separation in scoring, however. For instance, Fighter A could win two very close rounds by executing a couple more techniques in each round than Fighter B. The score for those rounds would be 10-9 in Fighter A’s favor, giving him a 20-18 lead going into the third stanza. Fighter B could then dominate the third round from bell to bell, maybe causing Fighter A to bleed profusely, but not necessarily put Fighter A in extreme danger of being finished. Fighter B, in such an instance, is often awarded a 10-9 round, thus losing the fight 29-28.

That’s when the backlash begins because of Fighter B’s strong finish, leaving the final impression in people’s minds that he dominated the fight. But under the 10-point must system, Fighter B loses the fight.

Is the Elkins vs. Omigawa decision that type of situation? Or did Omigawa get robbed?

The floor is obviously wide open to debate on that fight and the subject of scoring in general. And it’s a debate that isn’t likely to go away anytime soon.

Got something to say? Weigh in with a thought of your own in the comments section below.

Ken Pishna is the managing editor of MMAWeekly.com.
Follow
@KenPishna on Twitter or e-mail Ken a question or comment.

Follow MMAWeekly.com on Twitter and Facebook.

view original article >>
Report here if this news is invalid.

Related News

Mendes vs. McGregor Results: Immediate Post-Fight Comments and Top Highlights

  • 23 days ago
  • 5 views

Conor McGregor claimed the interim UFC featherweight championship on Sunday at UFC 189 with a TKO triumph over Chad Mendes in the co-main event at MGM Grand Garden Arena in Las Vegas. Just seconds be read news >>

Mendes vs. McGregor: Results, Highlights and Post-Fight Comments from UFC 189

  • 22 days ago
  • 13 views

Conor McGregor's meteoric rise through the Ultimate Fighting Championship entered new speeds on Saturday after he defeated Chad Mendes with a second-round stoppage at UFC 189 to clinch the interim UF read news >>

UFC 189 Fight Highlights: Robbie Lawler vs. Rory MacDonald

  • 23 days ago
  • 35 views

Watch the video highlights and post-fight comments from the UFC 189 co-main event between Robbie Lawler and Rory MacDonald. read news >>

Mendes vs. McGregor: Latest Comments, Weigh-In Info and Predictions for UFC 189

  • 23 days ago
  • 13 views

Both "The Notorious" Conor McGregor and Chad "Money" Mendes made weight for the main event scrap at UFC 189. Mendes was half a pound under the featherweight limit at 144.5 pounds, and McGregor was ri read news >>

Jeff Mayweather on Conor McGregor: 'he'd get his ass whooped by an amateur boxer'

  • 24 days ago
  • 56 views

Floyd Mayweather's uncle responds to Conor McGregor's comments on the Conan O'Brien show. Conor McGregor's confidence knows no bounds. Featured as a guest on Conan O'Brien's talk show last week, McGr read news >>

Jenna Renee Webb slams Travis Browne's manager for 'absurd' comments, explain why she went to Instagram instead of polic

  • 24 days ago
  • 37 views

Fitness model Jenna Renee Webb came forward earlier this week to accuse her ex-boyfriend, Ultimate Fighting Championship (UFC) heavyweight contender Travis Browne, of abusing her during their relatio read news >>

Lawler vs. MacDonald 2: Odds, Comments and Predictions for UFC 189

  • 24 days ago
  • 8 views

Lost in all the buzz surrounding UFC 189's main event between Conor McGregor and Chad Mendes is an epic co-main event between Rory MacDonald and Robbie Lawler. Usually the term co-main event is a bit read news >>

Chad Mendes defends injured Jose Aldo from fan backlash

  • 25 days ago
  • 9 views

LAS VEGAS -- Jose Aldo has taken plenty of heat from fans after he pulled out of UFC 189 with a broken rib and comments by Conor McGregor and UFC president Dana White have only added fuel to the fire read news >>

Conor McGregor on Chael Sonnen weight cut comments: 'Don't believe everything you hear'

  • 26 days ago
  • 36 views

LAS VEGAS -- Chael Sonnen whipped the MMA community into frenzy -- which he is known to do -- when he said on Jim Rome last week that Conor McGregor had to cut almost 30 pounds in eight days to make read news >>

Tonya Evinger Invicta FC 13 media day scrum

  • 26 days ago
  • 8 views

LAS VEGAS -- Tonya Evinger discusses recent comments by Sean Shelby, her motivation, why she would rather fight for Invicta than UFC, and more during Invicta FC 13 media day Tuesday. read news >>