Featherweight champ Jose Aldo's refusal to fight Anthony Pettis is misguided and short-sighted (Yahoo! Sports)


  • Share on Tumblr
  • submit to reddit

Almost as stunning as Liz Carmouche's near-miss submission on Ronda Rousey on Saturday was UFC president Dana White's late-night announcement that featherweight champion Jose Aldo is refusing to face Anthony Pettis.

Pettis is the UFC's No. 1-rated lightweight contender who, you may recall, texted White not long after Aldo defeated Frankie Edgar at UFC 156, begging for a featherweight title shot.

The media and fan base seemed to love it, and White announced plans for the bout to be held Aug. 3.

Following Rousey's UFC 157 victory over Carmouche on Saturday at the Honda Center in Anaheim, Calif., White said that Aldo and manager/trainer Andre Pederneiras didn't feel Pettis was deserving and were thus not willing to accept the fight.

"Jose Aldo came out and said, 'There's no way in hell I'm fighting Pettis,' " White said. "He's absolutely refusing to fight Pettis. [He] doesn't think he deserves the shot."

It's clearly a bonehead move by both Pederneiras and Aldo. There are few fights that could be made in MMA that promise to be more compelling than an Aldo-Pettis match.

This, though, is not a crisis by any means. White insisted that despite the protestations from Aldo, he will fight Pettis.

White pointed out the folly of Pederneiras' logic, noting that if Aldo were to choose to move up to lightweight – as has often been discussed – he'd instantly become the No. 1 contender there.

The same should be true in reverse. Given Pettis' status as the top lightweight contender, he should be the top featherweight contender, as well.

[Also: Ronda Rousey wasn't the only star at UFC 157]

Fighters can't be forced to take bouts they don't want, but champions are a notable exception. Once a fighter wins the title, he or she is then agreeing to face whomever is believed to be the most significant challenge.

There is no need for White, Aldo and Pederneiras to engage in a lengthy public war of words over the issue, however.

All White needs to do is to provide Aldo with a simple choice: Either he agrees by the end of the week to defend his title against Pettis or be immediately stripped of his championship.

Stripping a champion of a title won in the ring should always be a last resort. It's a major problem in boxing, where corrupt and short-sighted sanctioning bodies manipulate the titles so often that it's hard even for those who pay close attention to understand all the machinations.

There is little other choice here, though, as Aldo is taking a stance that defies logic.

Pettis' plan isn't necessarily to campaign as a featherweight. He correctly recognizes that a fight with Aldo would be a career-defining fight, one that would bring plenty of attention and money and would enhance the winner's legacy.

His goal, essentially, is to take on Aldo, one of the truly great fighters in the world, and then move back to lightweight to meet the winner of that division's April 20 championship match between Benson Henderson and Gilbert Melendez.

An Aldo-Pettis fight would be a major one in the MMA world. And then the winner versus the Henderson-Melendez winner also would be significant.

It would allow the UFC to put on two events that would be massive in terms of competitive significance and fan and media interest.

[Also: Biggest winners and losers from UFC 157]

That should always be the goal.

And so, if Aldo refuses to fight the bout that makes the most sense, the simple solution is to strip him quickly and not allow the situation to linger.

Stripping a champion of a title should never be a decision made easily.

In this case, though, the short-sightedness shown by Aldo and Pederneiras gives UFC officials little choice but to offer him the ultimatum. Champions cannot, and should never be, allowed to dictate who their challengers will be.

Other popular content on Yahoo! Sports:
Danica Patrick quiets critics, leaves family beaming with Daytona 500 performance
Potentially tragic heart condition sidelines top NFL prospect at combine
After leading the Lakers to victory, Kobe Bryant responds to Mark Cuban
Curtis Granderson injury puts Yankees in a bind
view original article >>

Related News

  • 26 days ago
  • 63 views

LAS VEGAS – UFC featherweight champ Jose Aldo’s injury won’t keep him from a rematch with No. 1 contender Chad Mendes.Filed under: News, UFC read news >>

  • 23 days ago
  • 29 views

UFC Featherweight champ Jose Aldo is injured and won't be able to defend his title against Chad Mendes at UFC 176. MMA Fighting's Ariel Helwani reported on UFC Tonight on Fox Sports 1 that UFC Featherweight champ Jose Aldo is injured and his UFC 176 headliner against Chad Mendes is cancelled. This is terrible news for Jose Aldo fans who have had to endure cancelled fight after long injury induced layoffs between rare opportunites to see their man in the Octagon. Since becoming the UFC Featherwei read news >>

  • 20 days ago
  • 36 views

UFC featherweight champion Jose Aldo has heard Chad Mendes’ comments, and he’s not pleased.Filed under: News, UFC read news >>

  • 17 days ago
  • 50 views

During a Monday appearance on the Sherdog Radio Network’s ”Beatdown” show, Chad Mendes weighed in on what he really thought caused UFC 176 to be postponed. read news >>

  • 24 days ago
  • 52 views

The UFC has decided to cancel an entire pay-per-view card after featherweight champion Jose Aldo was forced out of the main event with an injury. Aldo, who was scheduled to defend his 145-pound title in a rematch against Chad Mendes at the Staples Center in Los Angeles, Calif., on Aug. 2, suffered a shoulder injury that will keep him out of training for three to four weeks, and the promotion decided to cancel the whole event. The UFC announced on Tuesday that Aldo vs. Mendes is expected to take read news >>

  • 23 days ago
  • 56 views

UFC chairman and CEO Lorenzo Fertitta joined Fox Sports Live on Tuesday to explain the UFC 176 cancellation, providing a new target date for Jose Aldo vs. Chad Mendes II. read news >>

  • 23 days ago
  • 62 views

"Money" may get the title fight he wants with (or without) Aldo after UFC CEO Lorenzo Fertitta declared that the promotion would consider the possibility of an interim featherweight title fight if "Junior" isn't cleared by October. Chad Mendes' hopes of getting his revenge on Ultimate Fighting Championship (UFC) featherweight champion Jose Aldo were delayed after an injury to "Junior" forced a cancellation of their rematch; which was set to go down at UFC 176 on Aug. 2, 2014 in Los Angeles, Cali read news >>

  • 21 days ago
  • 1083 views

Jose Aldo is not happy about some of the things Chad Mendes has been saying about him, and leveled some serious allegations at the challenger in return. Jose Aldo does not respond well to criticism. The UFC featherweight champion appears to be on the boil, following an episode of the MMA Hour in which Mendes talked about his recently re-scheduled fight with Aldo, stating that Aldo "can't run forever," and that he would be taking the belt once the two finally fought again. Included in the expecte read news >>

  • 16 days ago
  • 51 views

The war of words between UFC featherweight champion Jose Aldo and No. 1 contender Chad Mendes over performance-enhancing drugs continued Tuesday with the latter's appearance on Sherdog Radio. Asked whether or not he believed Aldo was a PED user, Mendes seemed sure of it. "I definitely do [think Aldo's using PEDs]," said Mendes. "This is something that's been ongoing, but for him to all of a sudden just drop out -- I mean he drops out of a lot of fights -- but I think it's pretty coincidental." A read news >>