Diaz vs. Silva: It's Going to Be Fun, but Will It Be Competitive?

Fun fight.


Competitive fight?

Since the fight gods sent their messenger down from the mountains to announce Nick Diaz vs. Anderson Silva last week, there's been plenty of postulating on how the bout could be categorized.

Everyone knows that it's going to be a fun bout, a meeting of two of the sport's great personalities who also happen to be two of the most uniquely talented strikers in the game.

Diaz, with his tireless pace, inherent ruthlessness and lashing fists, against Silva's calculated backward steps, each one spinning a web to end with a finishing blow from one of eight incredibly deadly limbs.

Many would argue that it's a superfight, the first of its kind since perhaps Georges St-Pierre and B.J. Penn met a second time at UFC 94.

That's a term that's often thrown around too loosely and has historically been reserved for champion-versus-champion bouts (that almost never come to fruition), but with two of the promotion's biggest stars coming together here, it may very well apply.

But who can say for sure that it's going to be a competitive bout? For however long it lasts, it's sure to be enjoyable as a viewing experience, but it's hard to know what the MMA world is signing up for when it watches.

For all his promotional bluster, star power and in-cage savvy, Diaz has lost two straight and will be nearly two years removed from his last fight by the time he meets Silva. He's moving up from welterweight, where he's relatively undersized, to fight a man who has fought multiple times as a light heavyweight and never lost there.

On top of that, he's a stylistic delight for Silva, willing to walk forward until he wipes you out or he's vanquished trying. A lifetime of perfecting the art of counterattacking has equipped Silva with the tools not only to vanquish, but to vanquish in a fashion that usually finds its way onto highlight reels and video game covers.

The only questions that people have about Silva are his leg, last seen in two pieces as he was carted from the Octagon on a stretcher, and his age. How will those two things affect his performance, and have they robbed the sport of the Great Anderson Silva?

Diaz vs. Silva: Will it be competitive?

No one can say for sure, but it's not unreasonable to imagine that if his leg weren't capable of handling the rigors of the fight game, he wouldn't be cleared to compete by a doctor. It's also not unreasonable to suggest that, at 39-years-old, Silva isn't in his athletic prime anymore but is still good enough to perform at a very high level.

You don't go from the greatest ever to totally horrible overnight, and even with the injury layoff, it's hard to imagine Silva getting trounced by a smaller man who happens to be styled to play right into his hands.

They're all hypotheticals at this point: What will Diaz look like as a middleweight with two years of his prime spent on the sidelines? What will Silva look like at his age and after his devastating injury? What sort of kinetic poetry will they create when the gloves are touched (or not...probably not) and the brawl begins?

Nobody knows.

That's what makes it fun.

That's what makes it super.

If the right version of Anderson Silva shows up, though? There's reason to believe the world will know pretty quickly that it isn't competitive.

Follow me on Twitter @matthewjryder!

view original article >>
Report here if this news is invalid.

Related News

Luke Rockhold isn't going to go all Nick Diaz on Chris Weidman at UFC 194

  • 25 days ago

UFC middleweight title challenger Luke Rockhold vows to keep his composure in the Octagon against Chris Weidman, despite things heating up between the two middleweights. Middleweight studs Luke Rockh read news >>

Bellator releases rules for next week's 'Dynamite' light heavyweight tournament in San Jose

  • 23 days ago

It’s going to be a long night for one Bellator light heavyweight, but one that could lead to gold. Filed under: Bellator, News read news >>

Conor McGregor Bravado Slammed by UFC Middleweight Challenger Luke Rockhold

  • 23 days ago

Conor McGregor’s divisive persona means there are always going to be those associated with the UFC who aren’t huge fans. But it seems as though middleweight star Luke Rockhold dislikes the fighting I read news >>

Luke Rockhold on Weidman: 'I'm going to be his big brother his whole career'

  • 22 days ago

Like just about everyone who has challenged for a title through the course of combat sports history, Luke Rockhold is confident he has what it takes to upend the champion.Filed under: Featured, Featu read news >>

Luis Palomino on rematch with Justin Gaethje: It's always going to be a war

  • 20 days ago

Luis Palomino will get a second crack at WSOF lightweight champion Justin Gaethje when the two rematch in the main event of WSOF 23. Palomino expects the same kind of war the second time around, but read news >>

While support for Nick Diaz continues to swell, lessons to be learned in his mistakes

  • 18 days ago

Since a lot of folks are throwing around words like “arbitrary” and “capricious” and “travesty” in the wake of Nick Diaz’s five-year suspension, here’s another word: perjury.Filed under: Featured, (. read news >>

Bellator 142: McGeary vs. Ortiz Fight Card, TV Schedule and Predictions

  • 17 days ago

It's going to be a crazy night of MMA action in San Jose, California, on Friday. Bellator MMA and Glory Kickboxing are staging a cross-sport card that features what we hope will be high-level competi read news >>

5 Reasons to Care About Bellator Dynamite

  • 17 days ago

Bellator 142 is going down this weekend. That's right; this very weekend. Friday, to be exact. But the thing about this Bellator event is that it's not just any Bellator event. It's dynamite! And tha read news >>

UFC Quick Quote: 'Big' John McCarthy says Nick Diaz knowingly broke the rules, lied to athletic commmission

  • 16 days ago

I'm just going to flat out say it the way it is. Nick has been fighting for a long time, you know, and the way Nick fights Nick can continue to fight for a long time. It's a long suspension. There's read news >>

Coach: Nick Diaz to return to jiu-jitsu roots

  • 15 days ago

Nick Diaz’s longtime coach said the onetime UFC title challenger is “going to get back to his roots” as his legal reps attempt to appeal a five-year suspension.Filed under: Featured, News, UFC read news >>