Diaz vs. Silva: It's Going to Be Fun, but Will It Be Competitive?

Fun fight.


Competitive fight?

Since the fight gods sent their messenger down from the mountains to announce Nick Diaz vs. Anderson Silva last week, there's been plenty of postulating on how the bout could be categorized.

Everyone knows that it's going to be a fun bout, a meeting of two of the sport's great personalities who also happen to be two of the most uniquely talented strikers in the game.

Diaz, with his tireless pace, inherent ruthlessness and lashing fists, against Silva's calculated backward steps, each one spinning a web to end with a finishing blow from one of eight incredibly deadly limbs.

Many would argue that it's a superfight, the first of its kind since perhaps Georges St-Pierre and B.J. Penn met a second time at UFC 94.

That's a term that's often thrown around too loosely and has historically been reserved for champion-versus-champion bouts (that almost never come to fruition), but with two of the promotion's biggest stars coming together here, it may very well apply.

But who can say for sure that it's going to be a competitive bout? For however long it lasts, it's sure to be enjoyable as a viewing experience, but it's hard to know what the MMA world is signing up for when it watches.

For all his promotional bluster, star power and in-cage savvy, Diaz has lost two straight and will be nearly two years removed from his last fight by the time he meets Silva. He's moving up from welterweight, where he's relatively undersized, to fight a man who has fought multiple times as a light heavyweight and never lost there.

On top of that, he's a stylistic delight for Silva, willing to walk forward until he wipes you out or he's vanquished trying. A lifetime of perfecting the art of counterattacking has equipped Silva with the tools not only to vanquish, but to vanquish in a fashion that usually finds its way onto highlight reels and video game covers.

The only questions that people have about Silva are his leg, last seen in two pieces as he was carted from the Octagon on a stretcher, and his age. How will those two things affect his performance, and have they robbed the sport of the Great Anderson Silva?

Diaz vs. Silva: Will it be competitive?

No one can say for sure, but it's not unreasonable to imagine that if his leg weren't capable of handling the rigors of the fight game, he wouldn't be cleared to compete by a doctor. It's also not unreasonable to suggest that, at 39-years-old, Silva isn't in his athletic prime anymore but is still good enough to perform at a very high level.

You don't go from the greatest ever to totally horrible overnight, and even with the injury layoff, it's hard to imagine Silva getting trounced by a smaller man who happens to be styled to play right into his hands.

They're all hypotheticals at this point: What will Diaz look like as a middleweight with two years of his prime spent on the sidelines? What will Silva look like at his age and after his devastating injury? What sort of kinetic poetry will they create when the gloves are touched (or not...probably not) and the brawl begins?

Nobody knows.

That's what makes it fun.

That's what makes it super.

If the right version of Anderson Silva shows up, though? There's reason to believe the world will know pretty quickly that it isn't competitive.

Follow me on Twitter @matthewjryder!

view original article >>
Report here if this news is invalid.

Related News

Photos: 25 best images from UFC 205's news conference in NYC with McGregor, Alvarez first meeting

  • 27 days ago

UFC 205 is going to be one mother of a pay-per-view. Check out 25 photos from the news conference inside. Filed under: News, Photo Gallery, UFC, Videos read news >>

Stephen Thompson Thought He Was Going to Be Fighting Robbie Lawler (video) | MMAWeekly.com

  • 27 days ago

Welterweight title contender Stephen Thompson didn't care who won between Tyron Woodley and Robbie Lawler. His eye was on the belt, not the name. read news >>

Chris Gutierrez: 'It's Going to be Bad for Timur Valiev' | MMAWeekly.com

  • 19 days ago

Pressed into an immediate rematch, Chris Gutierrez said it's "going to be bad" for Timur Valeiv at WSOF 33 on Friday night. read news >>

Conor McGregor says post-UFC 205 announcement 'is going to be big'

  • 9 days ago

Conor McGregor has confirmed that he will make a major announcement after his upcoming UFC 205 showdown with Eddie Alvarez.Filed under: Featured, News, UFC read news >>

UFC Sacramento: Urijah Faber Gets Hometown Fight Against Brad Pickett

  • 7 days ago

UFC Sacramento was not going to be complete until the card added the town's MMA legend Urijah Faber. Now he is on the card against Brad Pickett.The UFC officially announced the contest on their read news >>

UFC: Gegard Mousasi Wants to Fight Uriah Hall or Anderson Silva

  • 5 days ago

UFC middlweight Gegard Mousasi has expressed an interest in fighting both Uriah Hall and future hall of famerAnderson 'The Spider' Silva.Just last month Gegard Mousasi was in Manchester, En read news >>

Gegard Mousasi will fight anyone, but hopes Nick Diaz wants to fight him

  • 5 days ago

The newly vocal UFC middleweight Gegard Mousasi will take just about any fight before the end of the year. But if Nick Diaz is really “ready to go,” he’ll welcome him back to the octagon. Filed under read news >>

UFC 207 is shaping up to be one of the best fight cards of the year

  • 4 days ago

The UFC is building an exceptional card around Ronda Rousey's return read news >>

Anderson Silva Apologizes, Dana White Accepts | MMAWeekly.com

  • 3 days ago

Thank goodness we have TMZ to bring Anderson Silva and Dana White together, keeping the MMA world in harmony. read news >>

UFC vet Cody McKenzie now works in marijuana production while fighting as he pleases

  • 3 days ago

“I’m not trying to be world champion,” Cody McKenzie tells MMAjunkie Radio. “I’m just trying to make money in the game.”Filed under: MMAjunkie Radio, News read news >>